I Love You Man is a love story, well sort of. Peter (Paul Rudd) a real estate salesman and Sydney (Jason Segel) a savvy investor, are in love. The problem is they are both straight men and Peter is on the verge of getting married to his fiancee Zooey (Rashida Jones).
While preparing for their wedding it becomes very apparent to Zooey that Peter isn’t exactly Mr. Popularity when it comes to the friend department. Peter feels that she might be disappointed by the lack on his side of the wedding party and with advice from his homosexual brother Robbie (Andy Samberg) and his mother (Jane Curtin), Peter begins a series of “man dates”.
After failing to find any meaningful connections Peter is ready to give up hope until he meets the eccentric Sydney at a showing for the home of Lou Ferrigno. Peter and Sydney hit it off immediately and start frequenting bars and spending a great deal of time in Sydney’s “man cave” rocking out to Rush and talking about their respective sex lives.
As Zooey starts to feel left out, Peter is forced to reconsider his relationship with Sydney and decides that Sydney refuses to grow up and if he wishes to move on with his life with Zooey he needs to refrain from the childish behavior that Sydney involved him in.
Not unlike most of the comedies that star actors whose careers were created by Judd Apatow, the arc of this story is quite similar. SPOILER ALERT: Cheesy guys doing cheesy guy things, conflict with women, everything ends happy. This one however has a much more interesting story and conflict and many of the plot twists defy what has become cannon in modern day comedies.
Rudd and Segel work extremely well together and although the comedy isn’t always laugh out loud hysterical, it is plenty to keep you entertained and wanting more over the roughly two hours the film runs. Overall 3 stars out of 4